Pull, not push

On not being the engine

Last week ended with a room that can argue and still decide. A room like that can take on almost anything. But it still needs somewhere to go.

So start with two questions.

If you asked five of your people what you’re all building, would you get the same answer? Would you get an answer at all?

And how much of last quarter’s momentum came from you?

Be honest with the second one. If the answer is “most of it”, you already know how your Fridays feel.

The cox problem

Rowers face backwards. They sit with their backs to the finish line, looking at the water they’ve already covered. The only person in the boat who can see where it’s going is the cox.

In a boat, that works. In a leadership team, it means one person supplies the direction and the energy, and everyone else rows.

A lot of teams are led like that. The leader can see the destination. The team can see last year’s numbers, the restructure, the project that must never happen again. So the leader calls the stroke rate, every week.

It works. A team driven from behind will move.

It will move as far as you push. And stop when you do.

Two ways to move a team

Push is energy from behind. Targets, check-ins, chasing the updates, leaning in harder when it slows. The momentum is yours. You lend it to the team every week, and you have to keep lending it.

Pull is energy from ahead. A future clear enough that people can see themselves in it, and want to get there. The momentum belongs to the team.

Pull doesn’t mean you stop holding people to account, or stop making the hard calls. It means you stop being the only source of energy in the room. Your job shifts from supplying the momentum to building the conditions for it.

Most leaders know this in theory. In practice, they announce the future once, at the offsite, then spend the rest of the year pushing.

What the research found

For most of the last century, psychology treated people as driven by their past. Habits, drives, history, conditioning. In 2013, Martin Seligman and three colleagues argued that this gets human behaviour backwards. People, they said, are better understood as navigating into the future: constantly imagining what could happen and steering by it. They called it prospection.(1)

That’s the case for pull. People move toward futures they can picture.

But there’s a catch, and it’s where most vision statements fail.

Gabriele Oettingen at New York University has spent years studying what happens when people picture a good future. In one set of experiments with Heather Kappes, people who indulged in idealised fantasies about the future had less energy afterwards, not more. In one study, they also achieved fewer of their goals that week.(2) Enjoying the future in your head seems to take the edge off the urge to go and get it.

So a glossy future doesn’t pull. It sedates.

What works, Oettingen found, is pairing the future with the obstacle. Picture where you want to be, then name honestly what’s in the way.(3) It works best when people believe the future is reachable. The future gives them a reason to move. The obstacle gives them something to move against.

That’s the difference between a vision your team admires and a future your team walks toward.

Pulling this week

Make the future specific enough to picture. “World class” doesn’t pull. Neither does “best in market”. A future pulls when someone can see a Tuesday in it. By June, a customer problem gets fixed by whoever takes the call. By March, the leadership meeting finishes on time because the decisions were made before it.

Let them paint part of it. Ask your team: “If the next twelve months go well, what’s different for you?” Then go last. A future you announce is yours. A future they helped describe is theirs, and people walk toward what’s theirs.

Leave the obstacles in. Once the picture is clear, ask: “What’s most likely to stop us?” Don’t argue with the answers. They’re not negativity. They’re what turns a nice picture into a plan.

And a plan the team owns is one you don’t have to push.

Back to the hum

This arc started with a week you couldn’t explain. The week everything just worked. Nobody was chasing. Nobody was carrying it. The team simply moved.

Rowers have a name for that. Swing: the moment eight people stop rowing as individuals and start moving as one. It feels effortless, even though nobody has stopped working. Everything in this arc has been about getting there. Reading your grip. Going first. Getting out of the way. Holding the line when it matters. Holding the room.

None of that produces hum on its own. It clears the way. The hum comes when the team can see where it’s going and decides, for itself, to go.

Next Monday, I’ll show you what that sounds like in a real leadership team, eight months in.

One thing this week

At your next team meeting, ask one question: “If the next twelve months go well, what will be different for you?”

Don’t answer it yourself. Don’t correct anyone. Write down what they say, then ask what’s most likely to get in the way.

Then reply and tell me what you heard.

Hum. The sound of great teams.

(1) Seligman, M. E. P., Railton, P., Baumeister, R. F., & Sripada, C. (2013). Navigating into the future or driven by the past. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 8(2), 119-141. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691612474317

(2) Kappes, H. B., & Oettingen, G. (2011). Positive fantasies about idealized futures sap energy. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(4), 719-729. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2011.02.003

(3) Oettingen, G. (2014). Rethinking positive thinking: Inside the new science of motivation. Current.

Jacqui Ferris