Holding the room

On the brave space

Think about your last leadership meeting.

Who did most of the talking?

What got decided, and would everyone in the room describe it the same way?

What was said in the corridor afterwards that wasn’t said in the room?

And if someone thought the plan was going to fail, would they have said so?

Be honest with the last one. It tells you what kind of room you’re running.

The room has a grip too

Every room has a setting, and mostly you set it without meaning to.

Hold it too tight and you get the polite room. The agenda runs to time. Everyone agrees. Nobody says the thing. Then the real meeting happens in the car park, and the team heads off in five different directions.

Hold it too loose and you get the loud room. Everyone has a view and nothing lands. The same item comes back next month, and the month after. It feels open. It isn’t kind either, because nobody leaves knowing what was decided.

Most leaders know which one they run. Fewer notice that both come from the same place: a grip set once and never read again.

Two things a room needs

Amy Edmondson’s research at Harvard puts it simply. A room needs two things at once: people safe enough to say what they think, and a standard high enough to matter. Safety alone gets comfortable. Standards alone get anxious. You need both.(1)

That’s the brave space. Not a safe space where nothing gets challenged, and not a tough room where people keep their heads down. A room held firmly enough to be trusted, and lightly enough to be filled. And that isn’t a setting you choose once. Some days the room needs more safety. Some days it needs more standard. The skill is reading which.

What the research found

Gary Klein, a psychologist who studies how people make decisions under pressure, uses a simple tool called the premortem. Before a decision is locked in, the leader tells the room: imagine it’s a year from now and this has failed. Everyone writes down why, then reads one reason out.

It works for a reason. Research Klein cites, by Deborah Mitchell, Jay Russo and Nancy Pennington, found that imagining an outcome has already happened increases people’s ability to correctly identify the reasons for it by 30%.(2)

But the bigger effect is permission. The person who would never say “I don’t think this will work” now has to. Disagreeing stops being a risk and becomes the job.

Holding the room this week

Be firm on the frame. Before the meeting starts, say what’s being decided, and how. Is this “we discuss, I decide”, or “we discuss, you decide”? Most rooms drift because nobody knows which one they’re in. Once the frame is clear, let the room freestyle inside it.

Make it someone’s job to disagree. Run a premortem on the big decision. Or ask, “What would have to be true for this to be the wrong call?” Asking for dissent lowers the cost of offering it. What happens next decides whether anyone does it twice.

Watch what happens to the first person who pushes back. That moment sets the room for months. Thank them, and use what they said if it’s good. Everyone else is watching to see what it cost them.

Close it out loud. End with what was decided, who owns it and when. If anyone disagrees, now is the time, not the car park. What leaves the room should be what was agreed in it.

The same move at every level

For a team leader, it’s the Monday catch-up where the same two people do all the talking. For a GM, it’s the monthly review where bad news turns up a quarter late. For an executive, it’s the leadership team that agrees in the room and heads off in five directions. The higher you go, the more polite the room gets, because the cost of disagreeing with you goes up.

One thing this week

Pick the next meeting you chair that has a real decision in it. Before you close it, run a five-minute pre-mortem. Then notice who speaks who usually doesn’t, and reply to tell me what you heard.

Not nicer. Not tougher. Reading what the room needs from you, and holding it that way.

A room that’s safe enough to argue and firm enough to decide can take on almost anything. But it still needs somewhere to go. You can push a team towards a future, and it will move as far as you push. Or you can paint that future clearly enough that they pull themselves there.

That’s next week, and the last issue in the arc.

Hum. The sound of great teams.

(1) Edmondson, A. C. (2019). The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. Wiley.

(2) Klein, G. (2007). Performing a project premortem. Harvard Business Review, 85(9), 18-19. Citing Mitchell, D. J., Russo, J. E., & Pennington, N. (1989). Back to the future: Temporal perspective in the explanation of events. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2(1), 25-38.

Rex Wood